i've had both. but fluffernutters are ALL work. you chew and chew and chew! theres no fun, just a jaw ache. peanut butter and jelly on the other hand has that light cold fruity jelly taste that offsets the warm thick peanut butter! peanut butter and fluff, together all time...are like men kept for unnatural purposes. peanut butter and jelly is...a classic love story, done right! like if adam and eve didn't totally blow it. THAT is what peanut butter and jelly are like.