Skip to main content
0 online

A NEW Contest!! A Biblical One!

skaorsk8 by skaorsk8 · Dec 18, 2002 · Trivia · 278 views · ·

Ok, this a real contest, not like last time, with no prizes. This time I am REALLY giving away a free trip to Mahwah. Seriously. I am not joking.

Here's the question. In 2nd Corinthians chapter 12, specifically verses 1-6, Paul comes off sounding like he's spent too much time on some kind of drug trip. According to Paul, someone he knows- possibly- has had an out of body experience- possibly. 14 years ago. Possibly. And whoever it was heard things he was not allowed to talk about. Paul really isn't sure. You have to read the passage in it's entirety to see what I mean.


So here's the issue. What is Paul talking about here? And what is the Third Heaven mentioned in this scripture? (Hint: the Insight books do not give a complete answer. You'll have to do better than that.)

To contribute to the discussion, please log in.

41 Comments

delliott101 delliott101OG 2002 ·

I'm looking at the SI book for this one... not interested in going to Mahwah, though..


So far, as I can see, there was a man who claimed that he was on his way to Heaven, but Paul could not confirm this was true, since he didn't experience it. This would have occured circa 41 CE. Paul said he knew the man, but did not identify him.


It appears he was suggesting that everyone take him at pretty much "face value"-- that he doesn't appear to be more that what he is... This is brought out in verses 6 and 7(a) "... For if I ever do want to boast, I shall not be unreasonable, for I shall say the truth. But I abstain, in order that no one should put to my credit more than what he sees I am or he hears from me, 7 just because of the excess of the revelations. Therefore, that I might not feel overly exalted..."


It could be this man was trying to draw attention to himself, exalting himself based on this "experience". Even though Paul had more confirmed, legitimate inspired visions, he downplayed those (unless when making a point) and let his visible actions (ministry, imprisionment, etc) speak for themselves.


That's what I get out of it... I could be off the mark...

skaorsk8 skaorsk8OG 2002 ·

focus more on the third heaven, my friend.

delliott101 delliott101OG 2002 ·

Well, I know it isn't the fourth away from seventh Heaven... going on a study, then I'll be back

skaorsk8 skaorsk8OG 2002 ·

double post, ugh. ian can you fix that?

iwz iwz ·

eventually i'll fix it. just don't click on the submit button more than once. ONE CLICK. then waaaaiiit.

ilikebirds ilikebirdsOG 2002 ·

so you're basically saying we are allowed to smoke weed because paul did ?

skaorsk8 skaorsk8OG 2002 ·

no. i'm saying paul had something mysterious going on that...oh, what the heck, go ahead. smoke weed. burn in purgatory forever and ever.

deanh77 deanh77Founder ·

According to Catholic dogma, purgatory is a bland place of lukewarm temperature where souls go to await judgement indefinitely. Not christendomic hell. (totally just made that word christendomic up)

delliott101 delliott101OG 2002 ·

And when Paul said he was stoned, that means people pelted him with stones.. so don't go trying to use THAT, Thai!!!

ilikebirds ilikebirdsOG 2002 ·

you , yourself said and not i.

delliott101 delliott101OG 2002 ·

I think I know how you think :-P

magnum magnumOG 2001 ·

you know if i win, thats 35$ u will owe me to goto mahwah

skaorsk8 skaorsk8OG 2002 ·

$35!! are you nuts! come on man i'll give you $6 for the GWB and you better be happy

magnum magnumOG 2001 ·

20$ for gas and 15$ for tolls buddy!

skaorsk8 skaorsk8OG 2002 ·

you're nuts. tolls are 12.50. gas is like, 3 dollars. At most. It's 45 miles from Nassau to my house.

delliott101 delliott101OG 2002 ·

Have you seen gas prices? I'm with Mag on this one!

skaorsk8 skaorsk8OG 2002 ·

gas up in jersey. save 50 dollars or so.

delliott101 delliott101OG 2002 ·

Ha ha... Dan, you still coming to Franklin on Sunday?

skaorsk8 skaorsk8OG 2002 ·

i was going to, but my mom apparently ordered tickets for me to see Footloose that day. So I'm going to Hawthorne instead. Sorry man. Next time.

delliott101 delliott101OG 2002 ·

No problem.... sorry I'll miss you...

magnum magnumOG 2001 ·

45 miles so round trip about 100, 20mpg at 2$ a gallon 10$ at least... but id like a full tank!

magnum magnumOG 2001 ·

you stole a image from the watchtower page, thats copywrited buddy ur goin to jail. Im reporting u, they gonna df' u too!

R
rocksupastarFounder ·

I think we should report him...

ok4now ok4nowOG 2002 ·

don't worry...the holy spirit internet bots have already logged his activity

g.f.s.rocks g.f.s.rocksOG 2001 ·

*** sl 131-4 8 A Spiritual Paradise on a Polluted Earth ***
4 Writing near the middle of the first century, about the year 55 C.E., he said to this congregation of fellow believers: “I have to boast. It is not beneficial; but I shall pass on to supernatural visions and revelations of the Lord. I know a man in union with Christ who, fourteen years ago—whether in the body I do not know, or out of the body I do not know; God knows—was caught away as such to the third heaven. Yes, I know such a man—whether in the body or apart from the body, I do not know, God knows—that he was caught away into paradise and heard unutterable words which it is not lawful for a man to speak. Over such a man I will boast, but I will not boast over myself.”—2 Corinthians 12:1-5.


5 The apostle Paul was here talking, not about some other man, but about himself. However, he speaks of himself, when having the above-described unique experience, as a man specially favored of God; and about the man that he was when in that highly favored position he can rightly boast. But of himself as an ordinary man minus such rare privileges from God he cannot properly boast. His experience was so realistic that it was as if he were right there in his physical body, but reasonably his physical body stayed on the earth and what he experienced was a trance and what he heard was when he was in this trance. If this experience occurred fourteen years before he wrote his second letter to the Corinthian congregation, then it occurred about the year 41 C.E., which was before his first missionary trip with Barnabas, which was about 47/48 C.E. Whether what he heard was in Hebrew or Greek, languages known to him, or in some foreign language that cannot be translated in known human languages, the apostle Paul does not specify.


6 In being caught away to the third heaven, Paul was not caught up and carried down the stream of time to the third of a series of heavens that followed one another in succession. He was caught up and borne vertically, and, as the number three or third is used in the Bible as a mark of intensity or emphasis, the “third heaven” would indicate the height of his elevation, the exalted quality of it. It did not acquaint him with the things in the heavens of spirit persons in the sense that Jesus Christ, who came down from heaven and returned to the spirit heavens, is acquainted with the invisible heavenly things. Figuratively, Paul was already seated with fellow Christians on earth “in the heavenly places in union with Christ Jesus.” (Ephesians 2:6) So his being caught away to the “third heaven” would indicate a spiritually exalted elevating of Paul above the spiritual position of his fellow Christians. It doubtless gave him insight such as he had not had before, and this would evidence itself in how he spoke and wrote.


7 As for his being caught away to “paradise,” this is here associated with the “third heaven.” This would suggest something spiritual. But this would not indicate that the paradise to which Paul was caught away was the one referred to in the message sent by the glorified Jesus Christ to the congregation in Ephesus, Asia Minor: “Let the one who has an ear hear what the spirit says to the congregations: To him that conquers I will grant to eat of the tree of life, which is in the paradise of God.” (Revelation 2:7) This “paradise of God” is a figurative one in the invisible spirit heavens, into which flesh and blood cannot enter and into which fleshly eye cannot see. (1 Corinthians 15:50) Nor is there any intimation that the apostle Paul saw symbols of things that are in the invisible spirit heavens in the way that the apostle John saw such, of which John gives us a description in Revelation, chapter four. So it is very unlikely that the apostle Paul was caught away to the “paradise of God” to see its “tree of life.”


8 As far as the original earthly paradise, the “garden of Eden,” is concerned, there is nothing mysterious to human creatures about such a paradise. It is nothing beyond human experience, and the restoration of it to earth under God’s Messianic kingdom has long been understood according to the Bible prophecies. (Genesis 3:8-24) Hence, the apostle Paul would not have to receive “supernatural visions and revelations of the Lord” in order to learn and know that.—2 Corinthians 12:1.


9 There is, however, another paradise that the Holy Scriptures picture prophetically, even giving us a historic prototype of this, in the land of Judah after the Babylonian exile of the Jews. This paradise is the spiritual one in our day, nineteen centuries after the apostle Paul was caught away to the “third heaven” and to “paradise” in a supernatural vision. What Paul heard during that realistic experience, the “unutterable words which it is not lawful for a man to speak,” were about this then future spiritual paradise. This blessed estate of Christ’s true disciples would come into existence during his “presence” or parousia at the “conclusion of the system of things.”—Matthew 24:3.


10 Paul was inspired to foretell the religious “apostasy” that would befall the Christian congregation before the “presence of our Lord Jesus Christ,” but it was not lawful for him as a man to speak about this spiritual paradise, about which he heard in “unutterable words.” To do so would have meant for him to interpret the Bible prophecies that have to do with this spiritual paradise.—2 Thessalonians 2:1-3; 2 Corinthians 12:1-4.

magnum magnumOG 2001 ·

haha cheater u copy and pasted, see the blocks they prove u cheated!

magnum magnumOG 2001 ·

cheaters will not inherit gods kingdom!

R
rocksupastarFounder ·

yea seriously, sucha cheater..... he didnt even try to hide that he was cheating...

deanh77 deanh77Founder ·

um, if you cite the source, you're not cheating. and he did right at the top of the cut-and-paste. was he supposed to just make the stuff up off the top of his head and hope he got it right?

skaorsk8 skaorsk8OG 2002 ·

GFS Rocks, actually finding the right answer (and in the right rare publication, no less!!)

Fortunately for me, youlive very close to Mahwah. This will be a low-cost contest.

magnum magnumOG 2001 ·

its called the watchtower library!

ok4now ok4nowOG 2002 ·

there's also an interesting point about when this vision took place, found in the w00 7/15 26,27.

skaorsk8 skaorsk8OG 2002 ·

Ok so should I do this agian next week?? or is it just a bad idea? I kinda wanted to put up some spiritual stuff on the site (so i could count it as time)...ok kidding....but, thoughts??

ok4now ok4nowOG 2002 ·

i don't mind...ask the taskmaster.

skaorsk8 skaorsk8OG 2002 ·

ok ian still no reply here...what's up with that..come on man drop a brotha a line...

ok4now ok4nowOG 2002 ·

are you pondering what i'm pondering?

skaorsk8 skaorsk8OG 2002 ·

i think so, but if chickens really poop eggs, why do we bother to eat them??

ok4now ok4nowOG 2002 ·

are you pondering what i'm pondering? (round #2)

skaorsk8 skaorsk8OG 2002 ·

i think so, but why do they have interstate highways in hawaii if no one can leave any island by car?

malibu malibuOG 2001 ·

QUESTION: it was brought to my attention at the meeting las tnigt about anna. didn't she have a cot set up in the back of the temple because she was never missing? but i mentioned it to my mom and dad and they both disagree with me but i seem to remember something about this.

ok4now ok4nowOG 2002 ·

the Insight book says this phrase means: "evidently from the time of the morning service until the evening service"

Welcome Back to eZabel

It's been a while. Here's what's new.

eZabel Lore

A complete history of our community — stats, Hall of Fame, legendary threads, and more.

View the Lore →

Everything Preserved

All 225,969 pieces of content from 2000–2014 are here — forums, messages, journals, photos, polls, and events.

💎

Gems

Spot something you love — a legendary comment, a classic thread, a great photo? Log in and click the diamond icon to mark it as a Gem. Add a note about why it's special. The best stuff surfaces on the Gems page.