Skip to main content
0 online
ilikebirds Nov 14, 2006

Giant will never win anyhing decent with ELI Manning as your QB. He is the most inaccurate passer with great receivers. Eli = garbage Rest of Giants team = good

thefunkyfresh Nov 15, 2006

nah he's good, if the giants can get to the superbowl with kerry collins they can win with eli. he needs to get more consistent tho

chuggie Nov 15, 2006

I've realized that without a star WR to bail him out, he isn't that great.

thefunkyfresh Nov 15, 2006

he's still top 6 or 7 in the league, who would you take ahead of him? peyton brady donovan maybe carson palmer maybe drew brees maybe hasselbeck maybe then who? vick? pennington? who?

ilikebirds Nov 15, 2006

definately vick definately pennington definately palmer definately donovan definately definately.. imagine vick back there? giants would be 8-1 at least penningtons accuracy? easily 8-1. eli...

C
chuggieOG 2003

I don't want to go into the hater category but since the game against the texans i'm not as enthused. He couldn't do anything with just toomer. He needs shockey to get YAC and Burress to bail him out by jumping and fighting for the ball. I think it just shows he's sloppy now and will improve. WITH a good receiver i'd take eli over anyone but brady and peyton. Otherwise i'd even take delhomme or Ben Rottweiler from the steelers.

thefunkyfresh thefunkyfreshFounder

i dunno, i disagree. he is streaky but when he's on he's awesome. as a giants fan, i'm happy we have him and he will only get better

C
chuggieOG 2003

yeah honestly he has gotten much better every year out..

Welcome Back to eZabel

It's been a while. Here's what's new.

eZabel Lore

A complete history of our community — stats, Hall of Fame, legendary threads, and more.

View the Lore →

Everything Preserved

All 225,969 pieces of content from 2000–2014 are here — forums, messages, journals, photos, polls, and events.

💎

Gems

Spot something you love — a legendary comment, a classic thread, a great photo? Log in and click the diamond icon to mark it as a Gem. Add a note about why it's special. The best stuff surfaces on the Gems page.