Saw Nightmare of You on Friday at Blend, in Ridgewood. I think I forgot to mention this sooner, but the show was great. The sound was really good - when they first started playing, I thought it sounded better than the CD!
Talked to Brandon (the lead singer) at the end for a bit, really nice guy who's kinda ... odd. Good show though, highly recommend it if you ever get the chance to see them.