Skip to main content
0 online

Star Wars vs Reality

B
by brotherman
· Nov 6, 2006 · 632 views · · · Journal

I know I'm gonna get branded as a geek by some lame-o, but it's an interesting thought I had.

The theme of Star Wars is the struggle to regain control of the force that has been overwhelmed by the dark side, by means of a chosen one who will bring balance. We see 2 important characters Anakin and his son Luke, struggle with dark side tendencies. What I find amazing is, those 2 characters could be any of us. We all have moments where anger could overwhelm us at any time and make us do something dark. But...we have that voice of reason, the light side of the force that always calls to us and pulls us back.

That light side is Jehovah's organization. At our darkest hour, when we are about to strike down our figurative enemies with all of our hatred, Jehovah stands in the middle, and extinguishes that notion. I think of Luke looking at his father's mechanical body that is now one hand short after hacking it off, and then his own mechanical hand that he has. At that moment the light side is shining through Luke after he had slipped into a dark tantrum. He remembers his own father's failure to listen to the light and now is faced with making the right decision.

Sometimes making the right decision then causes us great pain. Luke experienced the torturous bolts of lightning from the epitomy of evil, Lord Sidious, aka the Emperor, the very being who was causing the dark side to thrive. The light side allowed Luke to experience this pain, but it did not forget him, because Anakin was resurrected from the charred body of Vader, and saved his son. He fulfilled his purpose, killing off the Sith and bringing back balance to the force. In the end, good overcame evil.

So even though it may seem Jehovah might be forgetting about us, he will come to the rescue when the time is right. Our efforts will not be in vain. We have to keep plugging away and find that strength that is beyond what is normal. Only the light side brings that strength, and only it will conquer the dark side within each of us.

To contribute to the discussion, please log in.

113 Comments

superhero superheroOG 2004 ·

are news stories ever "pending approval"?

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Huh? You trying to say something?

web-toedchloe web-toedchloeOG 2001 ·

What if an interested person googles around and sees this post? Think it's a good witness?

R
rocksupastarFounder ·

What if one of ur co workers finds half the stuff that you say on here about them? Do you think THAT is a good witness?

web-toedchloe web-toedchloeOG 2001 ·

Please, man. That's completely different and you know it.

R
rocksupastarFounder ·

totally NOT! you are saying that something he says would be a bad witness... is it a GOOD witness to complain about all of your coworkers and say they are stupid and incompetent?

why dont you just agree with me and play Morrowind...

magnum magnumOG 2001 ·

Yeah and your pics of defiling your body with air canisters are a even worse witness HAH HAH HAAAAAAAAA. Its almost as bad as getting a tatoo! Take that!

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

What!! You're kidding right? I think some of you need to get off your high horses. This is the same group of people that find it ok to have Halo tournaments, listen to hate music, and watch South Park.

You want to explain to me what I wrote that was wrong?

R
rocksupastarFounder ·

awwww junk... he just said "hate music"... i listen to Enya... does that count?

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

I know some people on here listen to stuff that is full of hate. Not saying it's all that way, but you get my point.

Besides, Ian said this is not a Witness site. I'm still waiting to hear someone explain why I was wrong in what I said.

magnum magnumOG 2001 ·

YO DAWG why you be hating on me listening to FLAVOR FLAV YO? ME him AND SNOOP DiZOG are FRIENDS SON!

web-toedchloe web-toedchloeOG 2001 ·

I didn't say it was wrong. I'm just saying there's enough crap on the internet with the term "Jehovah's Organization" and I wouldn't add to that at all. All things are lawful, but not all things are advantageous.

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

It's obvious I was being symbolic. Everyone knows the Force isn't real.

R
rocksupastarFounder ·

well you are implying it by saying that its not a good witness... i dont see why this is a bad witness, i mean... incredibily CORNY and NERDY.. but i dont get why it would put any negative light on anything...

magnum magnumOG 2001 ·

Umm is that the dark side talking? I think you are trying to add to the negativity of the positivity of the negativity ANAKIN!

R
rocksupastarFounder ·

negative...

A
alexOG 2001 ·

i think you're reading a little too far into star wars there buddy. the apostle paul is probably rolling in his grave right now (romans 7 13-25) lol

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Are you seriously counseling me on this... OMG... Apparently you didn't understand what I wrote.

A
alexOG 2001 ·

i'm not counseling you, just making a joke, dude. chill.

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Oh, well that's fine then. haha... The Web princess apparently has a problem with what I wrote. I kind of figured you'd be the lame-o to rip on me.

web-toedchloe web-toedchloeOG 2001 ·

You know what? For me, it's nice to have this site to keep in contact with old friends. You don't fit into that category.

iwz iwz ·

Alright, enough guys. Lay off.

superhero superheroOG 2004 ·

yeah, mom! you tell them!

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Ok, I've never met you, so whatever.

C
chuggieOG 2003 ·

or technically in heaven but i got your point

PLEASE DELETE THIS

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

How about I delete you! haha...

A
alexOG 2001 ·

alright, alright nobody has any right to judge anyone else.

all brotherman did was make a comparison from a simple good versus evil story line in a movie, to the truth. you could do that with pretty much any movie. i don't see how it's a bad witness. other than maybe downplaying the entire point of the bible to the level of star wars, but hey jesus used illustrations too.

this comparison might actually work well for teaching some star wars sci phy nut about the bible.

now everyone cool your jets.

iwz iwz ·

The line between this being a public website and a Witness website needs to remain strong.

Having posts similar to this one on the homepage blurs that line. Therefore, I've changed the homepage to only display News Stories. News Stories should remain simply that: News. This post now can be found at its normal place: Journals.

iwz iwz ·

I've deleted the thread below. We don't need controversy of that nature on here.

A
alexOG 2001 ·

okay mr. zoo keeper...we'll go back to our cage...muh.

magnum magnumOG 2001 ·

IAN RUINED MY day off FUN. IM PROTESTING BY NOT BUYING GAMEBOYS! HAH!

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Magnum...Your hate for Gameboys has made you powerful...Now...Fulfill your destiny and take your PSP by my side!!

magnum magnumOG 2001 ·

woot psp!

ilikebirds ilikebirdsOG 2002 ·

haha i saw this on the frontpage and KNEW something funny/controversial was going to happen...
but i went all TL;DR and closed the page.. ANd nOW I MISSED ALL THE COMMENTS because ian deleted them
ARGHHHHHHHHH

magnum magnumOG 2001 ·

seriously it was some good fun man, u missed it

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

The dark side was unleashed!! Then Ian, Ezabel's own chosen one, vanquished that darkness. LOL!

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

I think some missed the point of what I wrote. I'm not saying that Jehovah's Organization is a literal equivalent to the light side of the force. The point of the story is, if you do your best to control yourself from doing seriously wrong things, Jehovah will remember that and give you relief in the end.

iwz iwz ·

I, for one, completely understand your point. But it's a separate issue.

For years, even mentioning anything about the organization has been kept separate from the homepage. Since eZabel 3.0, all of the admin controls are not yet in place, so editorial control has been a bit lax on the homepage. This is just an extension of that.

ilikebirds ilikebirdsOG 2002 ·

Get to it Gameboy!

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Yeah, Gameboy has been slacking.

iwz iwz ·

I know, I know! I've been soo busy with everything.. but I've been getting some motivation lately.

originalsnob originalsnobOG 2004 ·

motivation/harassment they're practically interchangeable

ilikebirds ilikebirdsOG 2002 ·

I get the point: You're a nerd!

Ohh hhhhh hhh

iwz iwz ·

/cue Triumph the Comic Insult Dog: HUGE NERD

ilikebirds ilikebirdsOG 2002 ·

For me to poop on

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Well if you looked at me, I certainly don't look like a nerd. Star Wars just clicks with me. I don't watch or read any other sci-fi fantasy.

ilikebirds ilikebirdsOG 2002 ·

I'm the most awesome nerd ever

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

I've noticed. You must get all the chicks.

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

He deleted yet another 10 posts. Wow, I am the King of Contriversy.

fivezero fivezeroOG 2003 ·

witness fan fic, ay yi yi

R
rocksupastarFounder ·

AW CRAP I MISSED ALL THE DRAMA

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

There was more drama? Where was I? haha

theremin thereminOG 2002 ·

This is an interesting read, especially since I've always felt the inspiration to make all the Star Wars films came from the Bible.

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Yes, the bible and the Roman Empire are big inspirations in making these movies.

flyingfree1125 flyingfree1125OG 2001 ·

interestingly enough i had this conversation with someone only a few days ago.. she said she refuses to watch any of them because the whole series was teaching that evil (satan/the dark side) will win over good (jehovah/ the force) She actually had this whole argument againsts Star Wars and its funny cause her husband loves them

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Actually evil never really wins. If you think about it, the time period where the Jedi are destroyed up until Anakin destroys the Sith is like our own history. The fall of the Jedi is like when Adam and Eve disobeyed. When Anakin destroys the Emperor and likewise the evil from within himself, it is like when the end will come and Satan and all evil is destroyed by means of God's Kingdom.

theremin thereminOG 2002 ·

That's missing the point really. It's not teaching that evil will at the end of the day, win. It's going right in line with reality actually, in that, it's true... evil has a powerful handle.. it's can easily take over anyone. That's how is it in this World. Look at how many people on Earth are in the world.. the majority. "The dark side" is the ruler of this system of things. I could be wrong, but I don't feel that Star Wars was made to show that the "dark side" should win.

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Well put.

Luke - "Is the darkside stronger?"
Yoda - "No...Only easier and more seductive."

The dark sides inability to eliminate all the jedi shows that good is going to eventually win.

C
chuggieOG 2003 ·

haha stop trying to force it to work. The Jedi universe stipulates that there is good and evil and always will be. And the balance to the force (the return of evil to power) was forced by that invisible force. So this force caused the evil to regain power and would not let good wipe it out completely. The jedi will win over evil but cannot wipe it out completely

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

The force was out of balance because the Jedi became complacent as the Sith grew stronger. The sith did not appear from nowhere. They always existed, but hid their presence for 1000 years. Once they were destroyed, evil within the force ceased to exist. Evil inclinations would always exist in the Star Wars universe, but the evil that corrupted the force was gone forever. At least from the POV of the movies that is how it is. I could care less what the books say.

A
alexOG 2001 ·

you guys are all huge nerds.

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

I'm gonna sick Mark Dodd after you...

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

And then I'm gonna take what's left of you and twist you into a pretzel...hahahahaha...

A
alexOG 2001 ·

ooohhh

B
brothermanOG 2004 · alex

You just peed yourself, didn't you...LOL!

A
alexOG 2001 · brotherman

actually i snuk up behind you and peed on your leg. you have pee all over you right now...HAHAHAHAAAA...sucker!

C
chuggieOG 2003 ·

i'm not talking books i'm talking from the movies. They never say that evil ceases to exist. And they never say that all the evil is wiped out in the universe and will never come back. Do they? I need facts here.

All I'm trying to say is that the philosophy they put forward is that, 'Good triumphs over evil but will never get rid of it so just try to be good and that is all that is required.' Which I think is diametrically opposed to the tenets of the bible and is subtley a pervasive worldy philosophy so I'd advise caution in advancing it with a newer person. And certainly not with anyone who is a star wars nerd, which i feel like right nwo

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Evil never goes away in the SW universe, but the sith do. The line of masters was broken after Sidious died. So after they are gone, evil is just kept under control. SW never was meant to be a direct comparison to the bible. It just uses biblical elements.

thefunkyfresh thefunkyfreshFounder ·

evil will always triumph because good is dumb

C
chuggieOG 2003 ·

I CAN'T BELIEVE YOU FELL FOR THAT MAN!!

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Yes, and my schwartz is bigger.

socalgal socalgalOG 2003 ·

i def get your point! well put!

socalgal socalgalOG 2003 ·

honestly, if you're witnessing to someone who's into sci-fi you can illustrate this to make them understand. i do that with movies etc sometimes....jesus taught us to use illustrations etc...something that the person we're witnessing to can relate. and this, many can relate. good job!

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

I don't really look at it as Sci-fi though. I look at it as a classic swash-buckling epic that incorporates some Sci-fi elements. The story of Star Wars is basically a mirror of human history in a way. That is why I don't understand why some call it lame. Star Trek is lame. It's too geeky for me. With Star Wars, you have a story that reaches the heart. It is the struggle of good vs evil. It is an emotional roller coaster, much like life in general.

socalgal socalgalOG 2003 ·

i agree. im not saying i dont. BUT the maj that're into it are sci-fi peeps...i was just saying you can use it as an illustration.

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Yeah, I'm in the minority though. I'm not a sci-fi peep. The sci-fi peeps have their own Jedi religion though. It'd be tough to get through to them. LOL!

socalgal socalgalOG 2003 ·

LOL

A
alexOG 2001 ·

okay ebert, what did you take that straight outta the star ledger movie reviews?

"swash-buckling epic" "the struggle of good verse evil" "an emotional roller coaster"

dude, you're lame...

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Strike me down with all of your hatred and your journey towards the dark side shall be complete!

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

BTW Alex, what kinds of movies do you like?

A
alexOG 2001 ·

uuuh...ones that don't suck.

C
chuggieOG 2003 ·

obviously a major difference is how there will always be the dark side and there is really no way to get rid of it in the SW universe...

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

The destruction of the Sith balanced the force. We are left to believe the dark side would never be in control again. Feelings of hate and anger would continue sure, but they would never overtake everything in the galaxy ever again.

C
chuggieOG 2003 ·

the series continues. Dark and evil keep going. It wasn't just the movies they have a whole series of books and such and no one knows what happens in the future. evil is never really gotten rid of

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

The books don't count. They are not canon.

C
chuggieOG 2003 ·

they're not the apocrypha

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Says you...LOL!

C
chuggieOG 2003 ·

lol or the book of mormon

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

For those in Hackettstown who see Mark Dodd do some odd stuff, he thinks he is a Sith Lord and tries to zap people. At least he does it to me. He cracks me up every time.

A
alexOG 2001 ·

this is really dumb

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

That is why you fail...

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Anger, fear, aggression...the dark side are these...

A
alexOG 2001 ·

all star wars is, is a cheesey plot line made worse by terrible actors, and dorky dialogue. exept for the ones with harrison ford, they all suck.

and did you ever notice that in the phantom menace, yoda looks like a muppet? in fact, the movies would have been a lot more intersesting if jim henson had written them rather than george lucas.

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Please...Episode 3 had the most powerful story of them all.

Uh, he was a muppet in the old ones too.

A
alexOG 2001 ·

a powerfull story line? haha compared to what? shrek 2?

A
alexOG 2001 ·

and that's not really saying much. just because it's story line was more powerful than the other movie's crappy story lines doesn't make it a good movie. THE STORY STILL SUCKS!!!

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

I'm saying it is the best of all 6.

A
alexOG 2001 ·

yeah, but it's still crap.

it's like saying "okay, i have six pieces of crap here, which one smells the best"

it's just like that. it smells really really bad, but compared to other pieces of crap, it smells great.

...get it? cause i don't think i can dumb this down for ya anymore.

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Wow...Someone is cruisin for a bruisin...haha...

R
rocksupastarFounder ·

ok.... let me sum up this thread so people dont have to read it...

Alex : Star Wars sucks, everything sucks, i hate everything, yada yada...

Brotherman : I love star wars ** random quotes from star wars that have no bearing on the conversation what so ever**

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Hahahaha......Yeah, good summary.

ilikebirds ilikebirdsOG 2002 ·

So Luke made out with his sister and his father cut off his hand.
Thats like armageddon

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Yeah well...Jo mama!!

fivezero fivezeroOG 2003 ·

Botherman, where do the ewoks fall in?

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Hahaha...That actually falls in line with the Roman Empire. In the end, it was barbarians and tribal people that defeated the remnants of that empire. So the Ewoks kicking storm trooper butt is a reflection of that.

fivezero fivezeroOG 2003 ·

Does Jabba the Hutt represent corrupt and stagnant people?

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

He represents yo mama...LOL! Just kidding.

I guess that could work.

fivezero fivezeroOG 2003 ·

Y'know, you could say I represent YOUR mama, if you know what I mean.

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

The dark side flows through this one... (evil Sidious tone)

fivezero fivezeroOG 2003 ·

lol, you can't tell me Dooku didn't look a lil like a pimp! with that fancy "euro-sabre"

you know this to be true.

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Well he is a Brit.

juicymango juicymangoOG 2003 ·

YOU PEOPLE ARE STILL TALKING ABOUT THIS

yes i said 'you people'

B
brothermanOG 2004 ·

Powerful you have become juicy...the dark side I sense in you...

Welcome Back to eZabel

It's been a while. Here's what's new.

eZabel Lore

A complete history of our community — stats, Hall of Fame, legendary threads, and more.

View the Lore →

Everything Preserved

All 225,969 pieces of content from 2000–2014 are here — forums, messages, journals, photos, polls, and events.

💎

Gems

Spot something you love — a legendary comment, a classic thread, a great photo? Log in and click the diamond icon to mark it as a Gem. Add a note about why it's special. The best stuff surfaces on the Gems page.